Michelin Primacy 4 vs Pilot Sport 4 (PS4) - Which Is #1?

Fuel Efficiency

The US Department of Energy estimates that around 25% of the fuel consumption of a vehicle is attributable to the tyres. That's a lot, and it means that choosing fuel efficient tyres can save you quite a bit of money.

The Primacy 4 tyres rank a C on a scale of A to E in the official fuel efficiency tests carried out by the EU (they call these rolling resistance tests).

The Pilot Sport 4 tyres also get a grade of C.

As their fuel efficiency grade is the same, expect negligible differences in fuel consumption between them.

Here's a graph comparing the Primacy 4 and Pilot Sport 4 tyres for fuel efficiency (1 = Grade E, 5 = Grade A).

Grip & Handling

We'll now take a look at how these tyres compare in terms of grip and handling.

A good measure of this is 'wet grip', which is an indication of how well the tyres will allow the vehicle to come to a stop in wet conditions.

The Primacy 4 tyres rank a A on a scale of A to E in the official fuel tests carried out by the EU.

The Pilot Sport 4 tyres, on the other hand, get a grade of A.

As their wet grip grade is the same, expect negligible differences in terms of braking distance.

Here's a graph comparing the Primacy 4 and Pilot Sport 4 tyres for wet grip (1 = Grade E, 5 = Grade A).

Noise

Another key factor to consider when choosing a tyre is road noise. Once you're over about 40 km/h, the dominant source of noise you hear is from the contact of your tyres on the road.

There is a surprisingly wide variation in the amount of noise each tyre makes.

The Primacy 4 tyres produce 69.0 dB of road noise, which corresponds to a rank of B on a scale of A to C in the standardised testing done by the EU.

On the other hand, the Pilot Sport 4 tyres produce 71.0 dB of road noise, which means a grade of B.

As their noise grade is the same, don't expect many differences in terms of cabin noise.

Here's a visual representation of how the Primacy 4 and Pilot Sport 4 tyres stack up for noise (1 = Grade C, 3 = Grade A).

Based on the results of a number of tyre benchmarks, the Primacy 4 scores 5 out of 5 for comfort and the Pilot Sport 4 scores 3 out of 5.

As per the UTQG guidelines, the Primacy 4 tyres have a treadwear rating of 340, whereas the Pilot Sport 4 tyres have a rating of 320. This means that the Primacy 4 tyres will theoretically last 1.1 times as long as the Pilot Sport 4 tyres.

As per the UTQG system, the Primacy 4 tyres have a traction resistance grading of A, whereas the Pilot Sport 4 tyres have a grading of AA.

As per the UTQG system of tyre grading, the Primacy 4 and Pilot Sport 4 tyres both have a temperature resistance grading of A.

For fuel efficiency, Primacy 4 score a grade of C, which is more or less average. Pilot Sport 4 end up with a grade of C, which is more or less average.

More important is the wet grip, which gives you an indication of their traction and handling. In this regard, both the Primacy 4 and the Pilot Sport 4 get a score of A, which is outstanding.

More important is the wet grip, which gives you an indication of their traction and handling. In this regard, Primacy 4 get a score of B, which is about typical. Pilot Sport 4 end up with a grade of B, which is about typical.