Pirelli Scorpion ATR vs All Terrain Plus - What's #1? [2024]

Fuel Efficiency

The US Department of Energy estimates that around 25% of the fuel consumption of a vehicle is attributable to the tyres. That's a lot, and it means that choosing fuel efficient tyres can save you quite a bit of money.

The Scorpion ATR tyres rank a D on a scale of A to E in the official fuel efficiency tests carried out by the EU (they call these rolling resistance tests).

The Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres also get a grade of D.

As their fuel efficiency grade is the same, expect negligible differences in fuel consumption between them.

Here's a graph comparing the Scorpion ATR and Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres for fuel efficiency (1 = Grade E, 5 = Grade A).

Grip & Handling

We'll now take a look at how these tyres compare in terms of grip and handling.

A good measure of this is 'wet grip', which is an indication of how well the tyres will allow the vehicle to come to a stop in wet conditions.

The Scorpion ATR tyres rank a C on a scale of A to E in the official fuel tests carried out by the EU.

The Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres, on the other hand, get a grade of D.

Expect the lower graded tyres to require about an extra 2 metres to come to a complete stop when braking at 80km/h.

Here's a graph comparing the Scorpion ATR and Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres for wet grip (1 = Grade E, 5 = Grade A).

Noise

Another key factor to consider when choosing a tyre is road noise. Once you're over about 40 km/h, the dominant source of noise you hear is from the contact of your tyres on the road.

There is a surprisingly wide variation in the amount of noise each tyre makes.

The Scorpion ATR tyres produce 71.8 dB of road noise, which corresponds to a rank of B on a scale of A to C in the standardised testing done by the EU.

On the other hand, the Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres produce 72.2 dB of road noise, which means a grade of B.

As their noise grade is the same, don't expect many differences in terms of cabin noise.

Here's a visual representation of how the Scorpion ATR and Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres stack up for noise (1 = Grade C, 3 = Grade A).

Based on the results of a number of tyre benchmarks, the Scorpion ATR scores 5 out of 5 for comfort and the Scorpion All Terrain Plus scores 5 out of 5.

As per the UTQG guidelines, the Scorpion ATR tyres have a treadwear rating of 440, whereas the Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres have a rating of 640. This means that the Scorpion ATR tyres will theoretically last only 69% as long as the Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres.

As per the, the Scorpion ATR and Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres both have a traction grading of A.

As per the UTQG system of tyre grading, the Scorpion ATR and Scorpion All Terrain Plus tyres both have a temperature resistance grading of B.

For fuel efficiency, Scorpion ATR score a grade of D, which is below average. Scorpion All Terrain Plus end up with a grade of D, which is below average.

More important is the wet grip, which gives you an indication of their traction and handling. In this regard, Scorpion ATR get a score of C, which is more or less average. Scorpion All Terrain Plus end up with a grade of D, which is below average.

More important is the wet grip, which gives you an indication of their traction and handling. In this regard, Scorpion ATR get a score of B, which is about typical. Scorpion All Terrain Plus end up with a grade of B, which is about typical.